The Nutty Squirrel
If you're ever in Eagle River, WI, and craving a delicious, no-frills meal with a welcoming atmosphere, The Nutty Squirrel is the place to be. Located at 3385 State Highway 70, this cozy spot has become a local favorite thanks to its hearty dishes and friendly vibe. Whether you're popping in for a quick bite or gathering with friends and family, you'll find the perfect setting here.
One of the highlights of The Nutty Squirrel menu is its mouthwatering variety of popular dishes. The Jalapeno Popper Burger is a must-try for those who enjoy a bit of heat with their meal. With its juicy patty, creamy cheese, and a zesty kick from the jalapenos, this burger is packed with flavor. For seafood lovers, the Broiled Haddock offers a perfectly seasoned and tender fish fillet that’s light yet satisfying. If you're in the mood for something rich and savory, the Liver is cooked to perfection, and the Ribs are tender and fall-off-the-bone delicious. There's no shortage of options for any appetite.
The atmosphere at The Nutty Squirrel is just as appealing as its menu. With moderate noise levels, it’s an ideal spot for group gatherings, whether it’s a casual night out with friends or a family dinner. The restaurant is also kid-friendly, making it a great choice for those dining with young ones. The vibe is relaxed and comfortable, giving off that perfect small-town charm that makes you feel right at home.
Whether you're stopping by for a quick meal or spending a few hours with loved ones, The Nutty Squirrel is sure to offer you a memorable dining experience. So, next time you're in the area, make sure to check it out—you won’t leave disappointed!
Reviews
Very comfortable with fair priced good meals to serve the north woods. The broasted chicken is very tasty!
Fabulous classic northern Wisconsin place. We started with an appetizer of delicious homemade fried pickles to go with our drinks - a local beer and the local cocktail: a brandy old-fashionedand a burger with a stuffed and fried jalapeño popper right on top, finished off with habanero raspberry sauce. Never had such a decadent crazy burger. It was delicious. And it didn't fall apart in the devouring.
We love this place. Just a stones throw from our cabin. It gets busy so if you want a seat/not wait for a while either get there when they open or try later around 6/630. Sitting at the bar is the best for us with attentive service, a strong pour, and fair pricing. Food always good too, we love coming here. They did take out my favorite gambling machine so that was a bummer but I am working on getting over it
Delicious and fast friday fish fry! They open at 4:00. We got there right away and claimed a spot at the bar. There was a line out the door waiting for them to open and they got everyone seating quickly. Once the tables were full they took a list for seating tables, you could grab a drink at the bar or wait outside for your table. They had several tables and games (corn hole) outside for waiting. I had the bluegill and perch platter with potato pancakes and my husband had the haddock and French fries. The batter on the bluegill and perch was a light panko coating and the haddock was more like a traditional beer batter, but thin and crispy. The platters were all you can eat, but the servings were large enough that we didn't need extra fish. They all came with baked bean, cole slaw, rye bread, and a side. The bartender managed to get dozens of drinks out for table service with in the first 15 min of opening while still being able to serve the bar. Do him a favor, if you want an old fashioned please be ready with the entire order, don't just ask for an old fashioned. He worked his tail off and was significantly under tipped ($1 for 5 drinks). Be kind to your bartender people. I highly recommend this for a great Friday fish fry. It was super busy but they seemed to be able to keep up. Be patient!
Our favorite place for Friday night fish fry in the area. Small, small dining room, so there is often a wait for a table, but the bar area provides ample seating for drinks and there's additional space outside in the summer for waiting. The all you can eat fish fry is great, and I love the combo option with the baby reds as a side. Normally, I'm a potato pancakes type of person, but my go to at the Nutty is always baby reds now when available. Cannot wait for the next fish fry here. Have yet to find somewhere in the Eagle River area that we like better!